Ohio Sports Betting Bills Face Stalemate, While Neighboring States Advance

Ohio State FlagAs of Spring 2019, two sports betting bills have been sitting, unmoved, in Ohio legislature:

  • OH SB 111 resides in the state Senate and aims to have the Ohio Casino Control Commission in charge of regulating sports betting.
  • OH HB 194 is in the state House and if legalized would appoint the Ohio Lottery as the regulatory authority over sports betting.

While it’s clear that these two Ohio sports betting bills have been locked in stalemate for months, the path to get out of it is unclear. With the Super Bowl only weeks away, sports wagering’s peak season, it comes as a shock that there hasn’t been a bigger push to move these bills forward, given the sensitive timeline.

Sen. John Eklund gave this statement last month, regarding the status of the legislature to this issue:

“The heavy lifting in terms of educating members, gathering info, caucusing, I think in my opinion, we’re coming to the end of that line. I know it’s taking a long time, but that doesn’t mean nothing’s going on. We’re working very hard to get this just so.”

Comments from the Speaker of the Ohio House of Representatives, Larry Householder, however, seemed to indicate different views:

 “The Senate at this point seems pretty committed to keeping it with the casinos. So we’ll just have to figure it all out.”

Ohio Falls Behind Neighboring States

Since Eklund’s comments last month, Ohio’s northern neighbor, Michigan, officially legalized both retail and online sports wagering. Kentucky, Ohio’s southern neighbor, has also sent a sports betting bill to their House floor and the bill looks to be in prime position to be signed into law with the governor supporting the bill.

Ohio now sits in between three states with active mobile betting that does not require in-person registration. That means that residents who live near the borders of Pennsylvania, West Virginia, or Indiana can all hop over the state line, place their bets, and come back to Ohio. This issue will seemingly only be accelerated when Michigan launches its own sports wagering apps.

Meanwhile, OH HB 194 has had a total of eight hearings conducted in the House Finance Committee since being introduced and has yet to reach the House Floor. Similarly, OH SB 111 has had two hearings in the Senate committee of General Government and Agency Review with no luck of obtaining a full vote from the Senate.

What’s the Hold Up?

What the hold up is really coming down to a disagreement over which state agency should regulate betting on sports.

Senate President Larry Obhof and Gov. Mike DeWine said they’re in favor of making it legal in Ohio’s 11 casinos and racinos, so long as it’s overseen by the Ohio Casino Control Commission. It would levy a 6.25% tax, with proceeds going into the state’s general fund. The Senate bill has only received two hearings so far.

Householder supports putting the Ohio Lottery Commission in charge, which could grant permission to small businesses like bars and restaurants and fraternal organizations to have sports betting terminals. It calls for taxing betting receipts at 10%, dedicating the net proceeds for education and gambling-addiction programs. The House version got eight committee hearings, but hasn’t gotten a hearing since December, with Householder saying it wasn’t quite ready for a full vote.

Both the Senate and House versions would allow for mobile betting, with neither version raising much money for the state. Casino companies generally prefer that the Casino Control Commission regulate the industry, though they’re not too pressed about which bill gets passed.

 

Ohio Racinos Hit Record Numbers via Slot Machine Gaming

OhioThe seven racetrack casinos of Ohio have reported record revenues via slot machine gaming with the recent fiscal year.

The state of Ohio is home to seven racetrack casinos, known as racinos. These venues offer slot machine gaming and during the recent fiscal year, the venues were able to hit record revenues. While the racinos did quite well, the land-based casinos of the state were only able to see small gains during the first portion of 2018.

Recent Revenues

On Monday, the Ohio Lottery Commission released the recent figures, with the fiscal year ending on June 30th generating $987 million in revenues from slot machine gaming. The racinos saw a 6.1% increase in slot machine revenue earnings based on comparisons with the same time frame from 2017. Over the past few years, the slots of the racinos have done really well, seeing a steady growth in earnings, growing as much as 1/3 since the fiscal year of 2015.

Each of the racinos in the state reported a revenue gain based on year-over-year totals. The Hard Rock Rocksino was the leader in earnings, with a 6% increase, generating $246.5 million. The Scioto Downs took the second-place position, earning $163.8 million while the JACK Thistledown facility was able to earn $121.4 million.

Land-Based Casino Revenues

When the racino slot machine revenues were released, the Ohio Casino Control Commission also provided the data from the first half of 2018 within the four land-based casinos. A total of $420.5 million was earned via slot and table game play, which is a 2% increase from the same time frame last year. Three of the four venues were able to see gains while one was not so lucky. The JACK Cincinnati was the lowest earner, bringing in $100.7 million, which is flat compared to 2018. The biggest earner was the Penn National Gaming’s Hollywood Casino Columbus, which brought in $115 million.

The racinos were able to outperform the casinos when it came to June figures, with $87.4 million generated, which is much higher than the $78 million from June 2017. The casinos only brought in $67.1 million which is slightly higher than last year’s $64 million. Table revenues helped the land-based venues to earn more for the month, especially considering that the slot games were down year-over-year.

The racinos and casinos are may soon be able to offer more if sports betting comes into play in the future. Reportedly, the gaming operators of the state want to get in on the sports betting industry now that the United States Supreme Court has ruled that PASPA is no longer valid. The Governor of the state, John Kashich, has stated via his office that he is considering the possibility of allowing sports betting in the state.

No movement has been made as far as legislation is concerned, so it would still be some time before any activity would be able to take place. It has been suggested that if lawmakers decide to legalize the option but have the same high tax rate of 33% as seen via non-slot games, then operators may not be too keen on signing up for sports betting.

Only time will tell what the state will do, but for now, there are earnings to be made via the slot games of both land-based casinos and racinos. It will be interesting to see if the increase in earnings will continue to be the trend for the state or if the games will see a change in earnings in the coming months.